« How to Roast Butternut Squash

Paleo Halloween Cupcakes »

Chocolate Whoopie Pies with Pumpkin Filling

chocolate whoopie pie with pumpkin cream filling recipe

When queried on Facebook many of my readers suggested I name these treats Chumpkin Whoopie Pies!

These Chocolate Whoopie Pies with Pumpkin Filling are not only gluten and grain-free, they’re dairy-free and nut-free as well.

Whoopie pies are little cake-like cookies filled with a rich creamy center. I’ve long wanted to make a gluten-free, grain-free whoopie pie cookie with a dairy-free filling. These treats are perfect for Halloween. No silly, these are not for your trick or treaters, give them out at a gluten-free Halloween party or just as a fun snack to your own little ghosts and gobblins.

These nut-free whoopie pies are based on my Paleo Chocolate Cupcake recipe another gluten-free, nut-free dessert recipe that comes in quite handy around the holidays. I hope you enjoy this whoopie pie recipe!

Chocolate Whoopie Pies with Pumpkin Fillingprint

  1. Pulse together dry ingredients in a food processor
  2. Pulse in wet ingredients until smooth
  3. Scoop batter onto parchment paper lined baking sheet, using a 1 tablespoon scoop
  4. Make sure to scrape all of the batter out of the food processor in order to get proper yield
  5. Bake at 350° 7-9 minutes
  6. Cool for 1 hour
  7. Fill with Pumpkin Whipped Cream
  8. Serve

Makes 16 individual cookies and 8 whoopie pies

Wow, what a great bunch you are. I’ve been having so much fun with you on Facebook this past week with giveaways and various conversations about food and just generally living a healthy life. If you feel like you really need to be in touch with me, leave a message on my Facebook page. I stop by and answer personal questions at least once a week and post recipes, provide informational tidbits and host little discussions most days. I’ve really been enjoying getting to know you all better.

Here are some healthy candy recipes to serve at a gluten-free Halloween party!

posted on October 23, 2013, 31 comments

  1. Claire

    Are the cookies bittersweet.? I’m wondering about the 1/4 honey? Claire

    • QueenJellyBean

      Hi Claire – the cookies aren’t bitter, but the sweetness is not strong. I actually forgot the vanilla stevia (even though I just bought it and it was sitting right there!) and just the honey alone made it sweet enough. I’m thinking a less-sweet cookie is a nice contrast to a sweeter cream filling.

  2. Karina

    Does can pumpkin work? If no? what kind of pumpkin? Ive never baked w pumpkins , only puréed (can). I really want to make these my kiddos ! Thank you!

  3. Alexandra @ Made to Glow @ madetoglow.com

    I will be trying these for sure! Love that they use coconut flour! I may try them with coconut nectar instead of honey. Thank you for sharing!

  4. Tami

    Will egg replacer get the same results?

  5. Janelle @ janellekibbe.com

    Okay… so something without gluten or dairy or nuts that has chocolate and pumpkin in it!? You are my hero! For real. I can’t wait to try these!!!

  6. Pink Peppercorn and Paprika @ pinkpeppercornandpaprika.blogspot.com

    two words. de and licious. thanks for the awesome recipe!! what a fun way to make the traditional whoopie pie season appropriate. I am looking forward to trying a peppermint version for the holidays!

  7. These look so good! What can I use instead of vanilla stevia?

  8. Tara

    Does anyone have an idea for how I could make these without chocolate? I know, they’re “chocolate whoopie pies” so it might seem silly to leave it out. But I can’t have chocolate and would like to have a GAPS-friendly way to make these. (I know, cocoa is allowed after a while on GAPS, but there are other reasons why I can’t have it, so I need another option.) Can’t do carob either. I assume I can’t just substitute more coconut flour, since it soaks up so much liquid and wouldn’t function the same as the cocoa. Maybe if I just leave out the cacao and use a little less liquid?? Anyone have other ideas?

    • Joelle

      I don’t know what you can or cannot have on GAPS, but I’m wondering if you use some espresso in them??

    • QueenJellyBean

      Hi Tara Dear – I was off chocolate for a year so I understand the need to sub it out. Some suggestions I’m thinking would work (these just came out of the oven, by the way, the regular recipe was easy).
      Idea A – 3 or 4 TB of a nut butter
      Idea B – 3 TB blanched almond flour
      Idea C – add cinnamon and vanilla to either A or B, above
      Idea D – grind up some dehydrated fruit (like blueberries or bananas), add 3 TB of that for flavor and volume

  9. Melissa

    Just made the cookies. I subbed maple syrup for honey, and I don’t have stevia so I added a dash of plain vanilla. They are absolutely delicious. I don’t think they will survive to be made in to actual whoopie pies. That will have to be another batch!

  10. Maggie

    How should they be stored (if not all eaten right away!)?

  11. Alana

    Since it’s Thanksgiving, I’m always looking for blogs that will give me plenty of ideas. My friend just told me about “Cooking With Mr. C.” on Facebook (also a blog). I just “Liked” his page. He dedicates November for all Thanksgiving ideas. I was hoping I may find some things on your blog this season too. Alana

  12. QueenJellyBean

    Whoop!Whoop!(hands in the air) I just made these. I ate 3 1/2. Quite good, and I didn’t grow up on Whoopie Pies. Here’s how mine went:
    – COOKIE: I forgot the stevia in the cookie part, they still tasted good, just sweet enough with just honey
    – COOKIE DEVIATION: I used 2TB of coconut oil instead of 1/4 cup. Worked fine. I just cut down on fat wherever possible.
    – CREAM: I used Trader Joe’s 14 oz can of Coconut Cream. I used a little more than half of that can, which was too much. If I followed the recipe and extracted my own coconut cream from a can of coconut milk, it probably would have yielded less than half of what I used. So my cream was too high in the coconut flavor, and way too low on pumpkin flavor.
    – CREAM: I added more fresh roasted pumpkin, probably half a cup total pumpkin, to my ‘too much coconut cream’. It was just starting to taste like pumpkin at that point. I would have no fear to try canned pumpkin another time if that’s all I had.
    – CREAM TEXTURE: was a bit like thick pancake batter.
    – STORAGE: I put the 4 leftover whoopie pies in the freezer on a plate, covered in saran wrap. On another hungry day I’ll probably eat it frozen.
    – YIELD: I got 13 cookies, although a really scraped for 14th. I got a small 14th but dropped it on the floor on the way to the oven. :-]

  13. Lulu Goodman

    I doubled the recipe for the Whoopie/cookie. Because my son can’t do eggs, I used egg replacer and pumpkin purée. Out if the oven and still warm they are so good. Will have to wait until they cool to get a sense of their density and whether or not they will hold up for the filling. I used EnerG mixed with coconut milk for 4 of the eggs and 1/2 cup pumpkin to replace the other two. Did not uses stevia and they are sweet enough.

  14. QueenJellyBean

    Hi Bernadette, The cookie batter was very soft, almost liquidy when I made these last night. That wasn’t a problem. with just one Tablespoon of batter per cookie, the batter didn’t run off the parchment paper. One possibility why yours was liquid . . . could it be due to the type of coconut flour – I always use Tropical Traditions brand (from Whole Foods or Amazon). A fine shredded coconut wouldn’t work with this recipe. Baking is so much trial and error, even following recipes exactly.

  15. QueenJellyBean

    Calorie Count – as I made it with only 2 TB of coconut oil in the cookies (instead of 4)
    Per Cookie Sandwich:
    Cal 194 gm
    Fat 12 gm
    Sodium 85 mg
    Total Carb 18 gm
    Dietary Fiber 2 gm
    Protein 5 gm

  16. Tracy

    Do you have a favorite coconut milk that you use? My coconut milk, though it wasn’t lite, did not have coconut milk at the top. And I did refrigerate it.

  17. Manya

    Thank you for your great and delicious recipes.
    I especially want to thank you for making them printer friendly!!!

  18. Lisa

    Don’t know what happened but the batter was so thin that when it baked, it all ran together. Any ideas?

  19. alex@ cakescookiesandpieohmy @ cakescookiesandpieohmy.com

    these were very yummy!!!

  20. rhonda

    LOVE your recipes! I love whoopie pies- how can I make them with no pumpkin, just a cream filling- without using heavy cream?

    thanks so much for doing this!!!!

  21. Holly Kaehn

    I have a reaction to stevia when used in the past. Is there anything else you suggest?

  22. Julia

    Did you used to have an almond flour whoopie pie recipe? I think I remember seeing one on your website. Thanks!!

Sorry, but comments are temporarily disabled for maintenance.

I'll update everyone shortly, but until then feel free to reach out on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter!
Comments are greatly appreciated! Unfortunately Elana is not able to answer substitution questions, as the only way to know if something works is to test it, and she does not provide this service. If you have a substitution question, please don't hesitate to leave a comment here, and another reader may jump in to answer. ↑ back to top