Vanilla Plum Jam

As fall approaches, my attention is shifting to our fruit trees. A few years back we planted a peach and two apple trees along the perimeter of our packed yard; they are now bursting with fruit, as is our dwarf plum. While we eat the peaches and apples straight off the trees, each fall we make a habit of picking the tart little plums and making our own homemade jam from them.

During this last weekend, the boys commenced with our plum harvest.  First, they went out to the yard and shook the fruit down from the tree.  Then they collected the plums in a large (unbreakable) metal bowl.  Next, we gathered in the kitchen and made this tangy fruit spread.

Vanilla Plum Jam

Print Pin Recipe



  • In a large covered saucepan, bring plums, agave and vanilla bean to a boil
  • Lower heat, uncover pot and simmer 15 minutes, until plums are dissolved (though skins will remain)
  • Cook 10 more minutes to reduce mixture, then stir in stevia
  • Remove vanilla bean, place plum mixture in vitamix and puree on highest setting
  • Transfer mixture back to pot and reheat on stove
  • In a small bowl, combine arrowroot powder and 1 tablespoon water to make a slurry
  • Bring plum mixture to a boil, then add arrowroot slurry, stirring continuously, until incorporated
  • Remove from heat, cool and transfer to mason jars
  • Store in refrigerator for up to one week
Prep Time 5 mins
Cook Time 35 mins
Total Time 40 mins
Tried this recipe?Mention @elanaspantry or tag #elanaspantry!

Feel free to play with the amount of agave and stevia called for in this recipe.  I used a lot of each sweetener because our plums are small and quite sour.  If you don’t have stevia, just use agave.  If you don’t have either, experiment with your own choice of sweetener.

I use arrowroot in this recipe (and many others) as a thickener, I’m not quite sure what would make a good substitute if you don’t have that on hand.  One solution might be to reduce the jam down to your desired thickness, cooking out most of the liquid. If you do find that something else works in place of arrowroot, please leave a comment and let us know.  In terms of using another fruit in place of plums, I imagine that might work –again, if you experiment with this, please share your results.

This thick gluten free, naturally sweetened, no sugar plum jam is delicious on pancakes, toast or warmed up over a big bowl of vanilla ice cream.

Tomorrow evening, September 17th at 5pm, I will be speaking at Pharmaca on Pearl Street in Boulder with Margaret Romero CNP, of Helios Health Center.  She will be discussing alternative treatment methods for recalcitrant celiac disease and I will talk about the social aspects of dealing with this diagnosis.


24 responses to “Vanilla Plum Jam”

  1. Hi there! I found this recipe while looking for a recipe to make peach jam (the Palisade peaches are plentiful and incredible right now). I’m wondering if the same recipe would work with peaches in place of plums? Thank you for your amazing, natural recipes!

  2. I’d really like a strawberry jam. Do you have a recipe for it. I used to make freezer strawberry jam but contained sugar!
    I love your website! It has helped me and my husband so much! Thank you ,Thank you.

  3. Hi there, could you use any fruit with this recipe please? Love your posts emailed to be in Christchurch New Zealand. Also just ordered a coupe of your books from Amazon! Jules

  4. I believe you could use Chia seeds to help it thicken but I will just boil it down to my thickness desired. Thank you for helping me make jams for my children to enjoy

  5. Hi Elana,
    I use agar agar as a thickener. Make sure it’s totally dissolved in a small quantity of boiling water before adding.
    Best wishes.

  6. Hi Elana,
    I just whipped this jam up. I found that letting it reduce a little longer, it was thickened by the time I was done pureeing it. I have to admit, this almost didn’t make it into jars, it was SO good right out of the blender, lol.
    Thank you for making jam possible for me again!

  7. Can you freeze this jam? I’m making such a big batch, I don’t think I’ll be able to eat it in a week’s time.

  8. I used honey (1/4 cup for 2 cups of plums) and no additional sweetener. But, my plums were very ripe. I also didn’t have a vanilla bean, so I just added organic gluten free vanilla at the end. Turned out great.

Have Something to Add?

Recipe Rating

Your comment will need to be approved before it will appear on the site.

Recipes » Condiments » Vanilla Plum Jam